Best For:
Music nerds who dissect lyrics, feminist media critics, pop culture junkies, country and hip-hop fans with a critical eye, and anyone who’s ever side-eyed a wedding DJ for playing “Escape.”
The Vault:
- The Piña Colada Paradox: A deep dive into how “Escape” masks a narrative of mutual attempted betrayal as a wholesome “wedding classic” through lighthearted production.
- Sexual Capital vs. Whimsical Infidelity: Contrasting Cardi B’s need to justify her “ring” through loyalty/labor against the narrative “get out of jail free” card given to male artists.
- Genre-Based Double Standards: How Country and Hip-Hop frame male cheating as a “whiskey-induced lapse” while punishing female artists with narrative “character flaws.”
- The Burden of Justification: Why women in music are forced to package desire in empowerment or irony, while men are afforded the default freedom to be “philosophers of lust.“
The Piña Colada Problem:
Music has always been a battleground for desire. But if you listen closely, really listen… you’ll notice something that cuts across pop, country, rap, and rock: men can sing about infidelity however they want.
Yes, just men…
You and I both know that women are still fighting for the ability to sing about their partner sexually without being shit-talked.
Rupert Holmes gave us “Escape (The Piña Colada Song),” a lighthearted romp about a man so bored with his partner that he places a personal ad to find someone new.
The twist?
The respondent ironically was his own wife, and then they both just laugh it off.
It’s a wedding staple… let that sink in a moment.
A “karaoke classic.”
A song about attempted cheating that somehow wants to feels wholesome.
“Escape (The Piña Colada Song),”hit #1 on December 22, 1979, and held the spot into January 1980, making the “classic” though I’m not gonna lie I won’t deny its catchy) literal bridge between decades and the anthem for the ‘me-first’ culture of the 80s
Meanwhile, Cardi B raps, “I don’t cook, I don’t clean, but let me tell you how I got this ring,” and the subtext is clear: outside of her career she doesn’t do traditional wife shit in a committed relationship is tied to what she provides sexually and how she navigates loyalty.
Cardi’s song was not a whimsical steel-drum moment about seeking excitement elsewhere.. while married.
Yet, She has to justify her position, and in a supposedly much more progressive era.
We both know this is not about prudishness or politeness. I for one don’t think don’t that modern television is too much smut, but I know our tv shows would give grandmas from the no-shared-beds on television a heart attack!
Honestly, if you as me… most openminded and honest individuals can see the fundamental double standard in who gets to be casually, complexly, and consequentially human in their art.
The Trope – Cheating as aQuirky Rom-Com:
“Escape” is a masterclass in narrative sleight of hand. The male protagonist is bored. So he writes a personal ad. His wife responds with the intent to have an affair.
The song should, by any logical measure, be about betrayal. But Holmes frames it as fate.
The light percussion,
singalong chorus,
and ironic twist…
all work to absolve the narrator.
He wasn’t really cheating.
He was only looking for connection.
He just happened to discover it again with his wife because if another woman would have answered, the same thing would have happened. Yet, the takeaway is somehow seen as romantic: they found each other again.
But here’s the part nobody talks about:
Holmes’s character could have taken all that energy:
- the plotting
- the personal ad
- the secret meetup
& simply reinvested it into his existing relationship.
He could have asked his partner what she liked… probably years ago.
He could have tried to rekindle the flame instead of shopping for a replacement. Yet, that’s not what he chose to do though.
But as most stories seem to go… He’s just a man so, of course…”oh, you know boys will be boys…” said about a grown ass bum.
The song and listeners reward him for it.
We can see the double standard in action. A male artist gets to take the most roundabout, borderline-unfaithful path to reconnection and still come out looking like a romantic hero.
We all know that a female artist attempting the same narrative would be eviscerated.
Cardi B & the Burden of Proving Worth:
Cardi B operates in a space where male rappers never have to. Her music frequently addresses the tension between sexual power and relational respect.
The now-famous line about getting a ring isn’t a boast about infidelity… it’s a boast about knowing she’s good at it and earning her rock through
desirability, implicitly, & loyalty.
When rappers like lil Wayne, Drake, and Future rap about wanting women like their objects, degrade them, and more they’re often met by their songs being played back, shared, and turned up.
Cardi B. doesn’t get that same grace.
Her sexuality is constantly framed as either over-the-top or reactive. She rarely gets to simply desire inside her previous committed framework without facing immediate moral judgment.
The contrast is stark:
- Rupert Holmes makes cheating romantic and quirky in “Escape,” and somehow creates a viral wedding song form. Male rappers make an array of lyrically creative jabs at women and non one blinks.
- Cardi B raps about securing a ring through sexual capital and is called calculating.
- I mean look at Britany Spears…
One side is afforded the freedom to wander.
& the other is expected to earn their place.
Across Genres – Country, Rap, & the Unspoken Rules;
This isn’t isolated to pop, rap, and hip-hop. Country music has built entire subgenres around the double standard.
Masculinity & Country Artists – Cheating & Circumstance:
From classic outlaw country to modern rock-country, male artists have long framed infidelity as a product of circumstance: the open road, a weak moment, a whiskey-induced lapse in judgment.
The protagonist remains sympathetic. Songs like “Whiskey Bent and Hell Bound” or even more contemporary tracks treat cheating as something that happens to a man rather than something he actively chooses.
Women Country Artists – Cheating as Character Flaw
Women in country singing about infidelity, are almost always the wronged party (Carrie Underwood’s “Before He Cheats”) or, if they stray, they face narrative punishment. Miranda Lambert has faced significant backlash for songs where she steps out, even when the context is neglect. The genre simply doesn’t allow women the same “boys will be boys” narrative cushion.
Rap – The Loyalty Double Bind:
In hip-hop, the divide is even more pronounced. Male rappers can cycle through explicit desires for multiple sexual partners while maintaining a real persona.
Women like Megan Thee Stallion or CupcakKe often have to wrap their explorations of desire in irony, humor, or overt empowerment framing just to avoid being reduced to a single label. A man can be a “savage- lover. A woman still has to pick a lane, or get slut-shammed.
Why This Matters – Narrative Freedom vs. Moral Policing:
At the heart of all this is a simple question: who gets to be the architect of their own desire?
Male artists, regardless of genre, operate with a default assumption of narrative freedom. They can be faithful, unfaithful, searching, or settled, and listeners accept it as part of a complex character. Their songs can be literal, poetic, explicit, or whimsical. The response is usually that’s just his story.
Female artists are still fighting for that same freedom. When they try, they’re forced to package their desire in:
· Irony (to signal they’re in on the joke)
· Empowerment framing (to make it palatable)
· Relational context (to justify why they’re expressing desire at all)
Rupert Holmes got to make a whimsical pop hit about trying to cheat. Cardi B has to constantly assert that despite her sexuality, she’s a wife who deserves her ring. Rappers get to be a philosophers of lust.
Yet, woman doing the same would be called a whore.
I’d Rather Hear a Woman Run the Game:
I listen to a lot of different types of music. I enjoy the melodies, the storytelling, and the craft across genres. But I’m tired of pretending the double standard doesn’t exist.
I’d rather hear a woman rap about getting her lick back, running game on a man, or treating men the way they’ve been treating women for decades.
I’d rather hear Cardi B, Megan Thee Stallion, or any female artist embrace the same narrative freedom we hand to male artists without question.
Because here’s the truth is if Rupert Holmes’s character had just put that energy into rekindling his own flame instead of placing a personal ad, he wouldn’t have needed a cute plot twist to justify his behavior. But the song rewards him anyway.
It’s time we started rewarding women for the same narrative complexity without the ring, without the justification, and without the double standard.
TLDR:
We need to stop pretending that “The Piña Colada Song” isn’t a catchy anthem for the “me-first” culture of infidelity. From 1970s pop to modern rap, male artists have been rewarded for roundabout paths to betrayal while women like Cardi B are forced to morally justify their place in a relationship.
It’s time to stop demanding a “loyalty tax” from female artists and start rewarding them for the same narrative complexity, guts, and messy humanity we’ve let men sing about for decades.
Leave a Reply